Play-Based Learning Shouldn’t Mean Chaos
“You should have seen it, it was chaos.”
That was how a friend recently described an early childhood service she visited while looking for a new place for her son. There were children everywhere, moving from one thing to another, with very little sense of purpose or direction. The educators appeared to believe that because children learn through play, their role was simply to let them play. The children were effectively being treated like free-range chickens, free to do whatever they wanted, whenever they wanted, with very little meaningful involvement from the adults around them.
The thing about early childhood education is that as children get older, parents’ expectations of us change too. When children are babies, parents primarily want a safe, nurturing place where they know their child will be cared for properly. They want reassurance that their baby will be fed, have their nappy changed, be comforted when they cry, receive appropriate stimulation and, above all else, be kept safe.
As babies become toddlers, parents begin expecting different things from us, including support with toilet training, self-help skills, language development and emotional regulation. Then, when children turn three, everyone suddenly realises there are only two years left until school, and the focus quickly shifts towards school-readiness skills. Lucky we are a jack of all trades.
The important thing is that these areas of development do not happen separately or neatly one after another. They are all happening at the same time because, as children develop cognitively, they are also learning about their world, how they belong within it and how to interact with the people around them. A child learning to put on their own shoes is developing independence, coordination, problem-solving skills, persistence and confidence, while a child negotiating over a toy is learning communication, emotional regulation, empathy and how to function as part of a group.
Enter The Early Years Learning Framework.
The Early Years Learning Framework tells us that children learn through play. Parents do not always agree with this, but that is often because they have not been shown the deeper meaning behind what the framework is actually saying. In truth, many educators and early childhood services do not fully understand it either, and some interpret learning through play to mean that children should be left to entertain themselves with minimal structure or adult involvement.
That is not what learning through play means. The idea that “play is the child’s work,” often associated with Maria Montessori, does not mean that adults step back and leave children entirely to their own devices. It means that play is the way young children investigate ideas, test theories, practise skills and make sense of their experiences, which is why educators must give careful thought to what children are learning and how the environment can support that learning.
A skilled educator does not merely plan activities to fill the day. They plan meaningful experiences with intentional learning outcomes and thoughtfully arrange the environment to act as the third teacher. They observe what the children are doing, work alongside them as co-players, ask questions, introduce new language, add resources and provide just enough support to scaffold the children’s thinking towards a higher level of understanding. When children discover something through their own investigation, make connections and experience it within their play, they are far more likely to understand and remember what they have learned.
Learning through play does not mean a free-for-all. It still requires meaningful planning, thoughtful structure, intentional teaching and educators who understand when to step in, when to extend an idea and when to allow a child the space to work something out independently. Within a well-planned play-based program, children can develop self-help skills, social competence, emotional regulation, communication, early literacy, numeracy, problem-solving and all the foundations they will eventually need for school.
School readiness is not necessarily about whether a child can write their name, recite the alphabet or complete a worksheet. It is about whether they can manage their emotions, communicate their needs, follow routines, persist when something is difficult, care for their belongings, use the toilet independently and confidently participate within a group. There is little point in a child being able to write their name if they are still wetting their pants, cannot monitor their belongings or are unable to cope when things do not go their way.
Our job is not to choose between nurturing children, teaching self-help skills, supporting emotional development or preparing them for school. Our job is to understand that all of these things are connected and to create an environment where children can develop them together. That is what genuine play-based learning looks like, and when it is done properly, it may appear busy, energetic and wonderfully alive, but it should never simply be chaos.